Low Carb Toad in the Hole Recipe

Enjoy this keto friendly traditional British dish for any meal of the day! Low carb Yorkshire pudding? Oh yessss… epically good! Plus, it’s fun to make and looks pretty neat, tool! This low carb Toad in the Hole is quick, easy and ridiculously tasty!

I know what you’re thinking – could a recipe with such a silly name actually be good?

Definitely – believe it or not, this strange-sounding dish is total comfort food! And, because I love taking traditional recipes and making them keto-friendly. I do have a tendency to explore International recipes due to my adventurous palate… And, I get a kick out of recipes with playful names!

This British-inspired dish consists of sausages baked in a creamy low carb Yorkshire pudding batter, served up with a divine onion and mushroom gravy. Seriously, if you’ve never heard of this or have never had it, you’re in for a special surprise.

And, this recipe is so easy and cooks up in no time! So easy, so delicious! Once you’ve tried it, you’ll probably add this in to your regular menu rotation!

Why is Toad in the Hole called toad in the hole?

I love British dishes and am incredibly fond of some of their odd names for traditional delicacies, like Bubble and Squeak and Spotted Dick. But the recipe title Toad in the Hole comes from an amusing local legend from somewhere around the town of Alnmouth, in Northumberland. Or at least I think it does… Honestly, there’s no clear story about the name, but here’s the one I know of…

Some say that during a golf tournament, a golfer putted a ball into a hole where a large frog happened to be sleeping. The irate toad popped the ball out of the hole, peering angrily at the golfers. The chef at the hotel that hosted the tournament created a dish to commemorate this hilarious event by baking sausages in a batter that is supposed to look like toads peering out of golf holes.

See the resemblance there? Nope – me either… But it’s a cute story, nevertheless.

I do believe this dish does come from a more traditional practice that was begun the 18th century where meat was added to a batter-based dish. This was a creative way to stretch out expensive protein and feed the family a filling meal at low cost. It’s a brilliant way to take lower cost cuts of meat (like sausage) and create an extravagant meal!

What exactly is Yorkshire pudding?

Interestingly enough, Yorkshire puddings have nothing to do with dessert. Yorkshires are a savory batter cooked in a hot oven that puff up considerably around the edges. The edges should be crisp, the center tender, soft and moist and should always be served with a tasty onion gravy.

Is this keto Yorkshire pudding traditional?

No, not exactly, but it comes close. It’s a bit of a challenge to get that Yorkshire pudding rise using a low carb flour, but this recipe certainly comes close! It’s tender and savory and is a perfect compliment to any sausage (or meat!).

I use fine almond flour for this recipe and found it works really well! And I love using my cast iron skillet. They cook so evenly and this dish just looks pretty cool in them, too!

What kind of sausage is used for Toad in the Hole?

You can use whatever sausage that suits your fancy! Try anything from kielbasa to andouille sausage.

You don’t even have to use sausage. Try making meatballs (cooked first) or adding a savory, cooked meat like lamb or baked, seasoned poultry.

How to make Toad in the Hole

This easy-squeezy recipe takes a few basic ingredients that are probably already in your pantry.

It’s as simple as browning the sausages, whipping up a quick batter and popping it in the oven. While it’s baking, the onion gravy pretty much cooks itself.

Optional add-ins:

While Toad in the Hole typically is only batter and meat, I like to add a few veggies. It’s difficult for me to make a dish with NO vegetables in it – except for maybe a dessert… If you don’t want to add any, I won’t hold it against you!

But if you do want to add some, you can add any vegetables that you would normally add to a frittata or quiche such as: broccoli, zucchini, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, spinach, etc. For this recipe, I added a few stems of broccolini, red onion and cherry tomatoes.

Can I make this a low-FODMAP Toad in the Hole?

Of course!! The trick is to find a low-FODMAP sausage. However, you can use any meat or make your own homemade sausage to add!

The batter is low-FODMAP but the gravy needs just a couple of tweaks to make it compliant. Instead of using sliced onion, use sliced leek tops or green onions – the green parts only. Replace the cremini or button mushrooms with oyster mushrooms – yes, those are low-FODMAP in small amounts!

Grab a skillet and let’s get cooking!!

Other recipes you might like

• Pisto Manchego with Baked Eggs
• Pumpkin Porridge with Maple Pecan Syrup
• Mediterranean Stir Fry with Skordalia
• Indian Spiced Salmon

This post contains affiliate links. As an Instacart and Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Print